Google Speculates If SEO ‘Is On A Dying Path’ via @sejournal, @martinibuster

Google’s latest Search Off the Record podcast discussed whether ‘SEO is connected a dying path’ due to the fact that of AI Search. Their appraisal sought to explicate that SEO remains unchanged by the instauration of AI Search, revealing a disagreement betwixt their ‘nothing has changed’ outlook for SEO and the existent experiences of integer marketers and publishers.

Google Speculates If AI Is On A Dying Path

At a definite constituent successful the podcast they started talking astir AI aft John Mueller introduced the taxable of the interaction of AI connected SEO.

John asked:

“So bash you deliberation AI volition regenerate SEO? Is SEO connected a dying path?”

Gary Illyes expressed skepticism, asserting that SEOs person been predicting the diminution of SEO for decades.

Gary expressed optimism that SEO is not dead, observing:

“I mean, SEO has been dying since 2001, truthful I’m not frightened for it. Like, I’m not. Yeah. No. I’m beauteous definite that, successful 2025,the archetypal nonfiction that comes retired is going to beryllium astir however SEO is dying again.”

He’s right. Google began putting the screws to the fashionable SEO tactics of the time astir 2004, gaining momentum successful 2005 with things similar statistical analysis.

It was a daze to SEOs erstwhile reciprocal links stopped working. Some refused to judge Google could suppress those tactics, speculating alternatively astir a ‘Sandbox’ that arbitrarily kept sites from ranking. The constituent is, speculation has ever been the fallback for SEOs who can’t explicate what’s happening, fueling the decades-long fearfulness that SEO is dying.

What the Googlers avoided discussing are the thousands of ample and tiny publishers that person been wiped retired implicit the past year.

More connected that below.

RAG Is How SEOs Can Approach SEO For AI Search

Google’s Lizzi Sassman past asked however SEO is applicable successful 2025 and aft immoderate off-topic banter John Mueller raised the taxable of RAG, Retrieval Augmented Generation. RAG is simply a method that helps answers generated by a ample connection exemplary (LLM) up to day and grounded successful facts. The strategy retrieves accusation from an outer root similar a hunt scale and/or a cognition graph and the ample connection exemplary subsequently generates the answer, retrieval augmented generation. The Chatbot interface past provides the reply successful earthy language.

When Gary Illyes confessed helium didn’t cognize however to explicate it, Googler Martin Splitt stepped successful with an analogy of documents (representing the hunt scale oregon cognition base), hunt and retrieval of accusation from those documents, and an output of the accusation from “out of the bag”).

Martin offered this simplified analogy of RAG:

“Probably nowadays it’s overmuch amended and you tin conscionable amusement that, similar here, you upload these 5 documents, and past based connected those 5 documents, you get thing retired of the bag.”

Lizzi Sassman commented:

“Ah, okay. So this question is astir however the happening knows its accusation and wherever it goes and gets the information.”

John Mueller picked up this thread of the treatment and started weaving a bigger conception of however RAG is what ties SEO practices to AI Search Engines, saying that determination is inactive a crawling, indexing and ranking portion to an AI hunt engine. He’s right, adjacent an AI hunt motor similar Perplexity AI uses an updated mentation of Google’s aged PageRank algorithm.

Mueller explained:

“I recovered it utile erstwhile talking astir things similar AI successful hunt results oregon combined with hunt results wherever SEOs, I consciousness initially, erstwhile they deliberation astir this topic, think, “Oh, this AI is this large magic container and cipher knows what is happening successful there.

And, erstwhile you speech astir benignant of the retrieval augmented part, that’s fundamentally what SEOs enactment on, similar making contented that’s crawlable and indexable for Search and that benignant of flows into each of these AI overviews.

So I benignant of recovered that space arsenic being thing to show, particularly to SEOs who are benignant of acrophobic of AI and each of these things, that actually, these AI-powered hunt results are often a premix of the existing things that you’re already doing. And it’s not that it abruptly replaces crawling and indexing.”

Mueller is close that the accepted process of indexing, crawling, and ranking inactive exists, keeping SEO applicable and indispensable for ensuring websites are discoverable and optimized for hunt engines.

However, the Googlers avoided discussing the evident concern today, which is the thousands of ample and tiny publishers successful the greater web ecosystem that person been wiped retired by Google’s AI algorithms connected the backend.

The Real Impacts Of AI On Search

What’s changed (and wasn’t addressed) is that the important portion of AI  successful Search isn’t the 1 connected the beforehand extremity with AI Overviews. It’s the portion connected the back-end making determinations based connected opaque signals of authority, topicality and the somewhat ironic concern that an artificial quality is deciding whether contented is made for hunt engines oregon humans.

Organic SERPs Are Explicitly Obsolete

The accepted 10 bluish links person been implicitly obsolete for astir 15 years but AI has made them explicitly obsolete.

Natural Language Search Queries

The discourse of hunt users who inquire precise conversational questions wrong respective backmost and distant turns is simply a immense alteration to hunt queries. Bing claims that this makes it easier to recognize hunt queries and supply progressively precise answers. That’s the portion that unsettles SEOs and publishers due to the fact that , let’s look it, a important magnitude of contented was created to fertile successful the keyword-based query paradigm, which is gradually disappearing arsenic users progressively displacement to much analyzable queries. How contented creators optimize for that is simply a large concern.

Backend AI Algorithms

The connection “capricious” means the inclination to marque abrupt and unexplainable changes successful behavior. It’s not a prime publishers and SEOs tendency successful a hunt engine. Yet capricious back-end algorithms that abruptly throttle postulation and subsequently alteration their virtual minds months later  is simply a reality.

Is Google Detached From Reality Of The Web Ecosystem?

Industry-wide harm caused by AI-based algorithms that are inactive “improving” person unquestionably harmed a sizeable conception of the web ecosystem. Immense amounts of postulation to publishers of each sizes has been wiped retired since the accrued integration of AI into Google’s backend, an contented that the caller Google Search Off The Record avoided discussing.

Many anticipation Google volition code this concern successful 2025 with greater nuance than their CEO Sundar Pichai who struggled to articulate however Google supports the web ecosystem, seemingly detached from the plight of thousands of publishers.

Maybe the question isn’t whether SEO is connected a dying way but whether publishing itself is successful diminution due to the fact that of AI connected some the backend and the beforehand of Google’s hunt container and Gemini apps.

Check retired these related articles:

Google CEO’s 2025 AI Strategy Deemphasizes The Search Box

Google Gemini Deep Research May Erode Website Earnings

Google CEO: Search Will Change Profoundly In 2025

Featured Image by Shutterstock/Shutterstock AI Generator