ARTICLE AD BOX
Before you start: if you’re unfamiliar with the principles of statistical SEO split-testing and however SplitSignal works, we're suggesting you start here or request a demo of SplitSignal.
First, we asked our Twitter followers to vote:
The bulk of our followers couldn't determine for sure, but the large quality is, we person each the answers ready. Read the lawsuit survey to find retired the result.
The Case Study
Over the years, determination person been galore concerns and discussions astir “boilerplate content” wrong the SEO community. SEOs person discussed however Google mightiness dainty antithetic leafage elements otherwise based connected surrounding HTML tags oregon their determination connected the page. While Google says it's mostly beauteous bully astatine recognizing boilerplate substance and says it won't penalize you for this benignant of content, Google’s wide guidelines authorities that you should minimize boilerplate content.
Almost each website has immoderate signifier of boilerplate content. Boilerplate contented successful presumption of SEO is substance oregon links that are reused crossed aggregate web pages of a website without importantly altering the archetypal content. Text and links successful headers, footers, oregon sidebars are well-known examples.
As an SEO, you privation to springiness hunt engines the close signals and assistance them recognize which contented and topics are important connected the page. This is wherefore we wanted to trial the interaction of heading tags successful boilerplate contented crossed aggregate templates of an eCommerce website.
The Hypothesis
To recognize what a web page's contented is about, Google looks astatine antithetic things, specified arsenic headings, to fig retired what is really being emphasized. Proper usage of HTML heading tags tin marque contented much meaningful and assistance hunt engines recognize the leafage and its intent a small better.
This led to the proposal that unnecessary oregon unrelated headings successful boilerplate contented tin marque your contented little meaningful and relevant, perchance negatively affecting SEO performance.
The website successful question utilized <h2> HTML tags successful the sidebar (on class pages) and footer (examples translated):
product pages additionally had boilerplate <h1>, <h2> HTML tags successful main contented elements (examples translated):
We decided to alteration each boilerplate heading tags to <div> tags. Note that this did not alteration the ocular presumption of the contented arsenic it is styled with CSS people selectors.
Only heading tags that stress superior content, specified arsenic <h2>product description</h2>, were near unchanged.
Control
Variant
The Test
We utilized SplitSignal to acceptable up the test. As mentioned, we chose to tally 2 tests, each connected a antithetic leafage template: class leafage (PLP) and merchandise leafage (PDP). Approximately 500 class pages and 1500 merchandise pages were selected arsenic variant oregon power via stratified sampling. We started the tests and ran them for 21 days. We were capable to find that Googlebot visited 99% of the tested pages.
The Results
After 21 days of testing, we reviewed the results of the 2 tests. We saw that for some tests, the postulation to the variant pages outperformed the modeled power group, meaning the tests were positive. Removing heading tags successful boilerplate contented resulted successful an estimated 3.9% summation successful integrated postulation for the tested class pages and an 8% summation for the tested merchandise pages.
When the bluish shaded country successful the cumulative presumption performs beneath oregon supra the x=0 axis, the trial is statistically important astatine the 95% level. Looking astatine the cumulative practice of the 2 tests, we tin reason that the effect became important precise quickly. This means that we tin beryllium assured that the summation we are seeing is owed to the alteration we person made and not to different (external) factors.
Note that we are not comparing the existent power radical pages to our tested pages. but alternatively a forecast based connected humanities data. The exemplary predicts the counterfactual effect that would person occurred had nary involution taken place. We comparison this with the existent data. We usage a acceptable of power pages to springiness the exemplary discourse for trends and outer influences. If thing other changes during our trial (e.g., seasonality), the exemplary volition observe and instrumentality it into account. By filtering these outer factors, we summation penetration into the existent interaction of an SEO change.
Why
The trial shows that Google surely gives immoderate value to definite HTML elements (such arsenic heading tags) successful boilerplate content. As mentioned, headings tin marque contented much meaningful and applicable to users and hunt engines. We tin reason that the other is besides true; Unnecessary oregon unrelated headings successful boilerplate contented tin marque contented little meaningful and relevant, resulting successful sub-optimal integrated performance.
Analysis of the information shows that the pages tested started to execute amended successful hunt results. Not lone did we spot an summation successful clicks, but we besides saw an summation successful impressions, suggesting that the pages tested became much applicable to the hunt queries for which the pages were ranked.
Headings springiness worth to the contented wrong the tag element. So it makes consciousness that emphasizing your superior contented and putting little accent connected alleged peripheral matters tin amended relevance.
While Google says it's mostly beauteous bully astatine recognizing and evaluating boilerplate text, the results suggest it's amended to instrumentality power and guarantee that the headings utilized connected the page help to stress superior topics and leafage content.
The result of this trial further piqued our interest, truthful we decided to rotation retired variants of this trial crossed aggregate websites. You tin expect much connected this taxable successful aboriginal lawsuit studies.
Keep successful caput that thing that works for 1 website whitethorn not enactment for another. The lone mode to cognize for definite is to trial what works for you!
English (US)